State election officials assess midterm successes, struggles
Regional News
Audio By Carbonatix
10:00 AM on Tuesday, November 17
(The Center Square) – Two of the highest-ranking elections officials in Arizona sang the praises of the men and women who kept the midterms on the tracks this fall.
Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes and Maricopa County Board of Supervisors Chair Kate Brophy McGee told The Center Square that this year’s general and primary elections were a success.
“I think we did a hell of a job,” Fontes told The Center Square.
He pointed to the state's success with its turnout despite a rainstorm that ended Nov. 1, but left the impact of flooding on Election Day.
“We had issues," Fontes said. "When the good Lord sending down the rain and washing out roads, there’s little you can do at the last second.
“Other than some of those physical access issues, I think we did about as good a job as we could," he said.
Maricopa County, which is the third largest voting district in the U.S. and is home to Phoenix, saw similar success, according to Brophy McGee, with 1,559,706 votes cast and 60.22% of eligible voters casting a ballot.
While that turnout was down 4% from the last midterm election in 2022, Brophy McGee said the state’s lack of a U.S. Senate race this year likely accounted for that difference.
All told, the first-term chair of the board said this year’s midterms went about as well as can be expected, with 208,658 people voting on Nov. 3 across 254 polling places.
“Maricopa County has always done a great job running elections,” Brophy McGee told The Center Square. “The trials and tribulations that we went through over prior years were embraced by county officials.
“They call it a process of continuous improvement, and they embraced those challenges. They worked with the Legislature on law changes and will continue to do that going forward,” she added.
John Kavanagh, who has served in the Arizona Legislature since 2007, including as the Senate majority leader in part of 2025 and all of 2026, told The Center Square on Monday that he hopes Fontes and other statewide leaders will balance election access with safety.
Kavanagh, R-Fountain Hills, said he was disappointed that Proposition 144, which would have added voter identification to the state's mail-in voting in addition to other aspects related to blocking foreign nationals from influencing elections, failed. But he added he hopes Democrats will balance voter's needs with their election goals.

Arizona Sen. John Kavanagh Speaks on Senate Floor
Senate Majority Leader John Kavanagh, R-Fountain Hills, speaks on the floor of the Arizona State Senate at the Arizona State Capitol in Phoenix in 2025.
"I think a lot of the things in [Prop. 144] were things that I agreed with. You certainly want to have identification when you vote. And I think it's a great idea to let voters bring their ballots with them on Election Day and have them counted right there," Kavanagh told The Center Square. "I think we need to remove people from the early voting list if they don't vote in any elections over a four-year period. You need to take these people off so you're not mailing ballots to people that don't want one."
Above all, Kavanagh said, he doesn't want to see Arizona's elections fall down the rabbit hole of corruption, citing the Tammany Hall days of New York City, where powerful political organizations were able to dominate local and federal elections.
"Having no restrictions on ballot harvesting is certainly a great way to introduce corruption because you're rounding up people who are more likely to vote for them," Kavanagh said.
Election takeaways
For Fontes, the historic rains that hit the state hard in the days running up to this year’s general elections actually showed the value of the type of in-person voting he wants to install statewide.
That voting choice is the implementation of voting centers, or spaces where all eligible county voters can cast their ballots, as opposed to neighborhood-based precincts, which Fontes wants to see implemented in the new year.

Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes
Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes. Photo: Courtesy of the Office of Arizona Secretary of State Adrian Fontes / Used with Permission
“We had a couple counties that had some issues historically that resolved those issues. The first one that comes to mind is Apache County,” Fontes said. “They switched over to vote centers, where any voter could vote anywhere in the county, and that actually alleviated some of the pressure from the washed-out roads up there, because that's in the northeast corner of the state. And a lot of those communities had issues, so they just voted in alternative places, which is great. So that worked out well.”
Fontes added he hopes the Democrats' newfound trifecta will allow them to pass his proposed Voters First Act.
The act, which was pitched in 2026 but never voted on in the Legislature, would restore the state’s Permanent Early Voting List, while also extending early voting to 5 p.m. on the Monday before Election Day. The bill would also expand vote centers statewide.
Brophy McGee expressed hope that the new year will bring in greater support for the more than 4,000 people who work to keep Maricopa County’s elections operations on the tracks each election cycle.
“I want to, as chair, build on the successes of this year, and move forward with that same mindset of a safe, secure, honest election,” Brophy McGee said. “I want voters to have a great experience and making that happen again in 2028. “
Fontes said his goal in 2027 is to knock down impediments to voting statewide, ensuring that Arizona’s voters have a streamlined way to cast their ballots, while promoting the safety of the men and women who work behind the scenes keep elections safe and secure.
“We're not asking for outrageous stuff. We're not asking for big, bloated budgets,” Fontes said. “We've been very consistently asking for essentially the same things for years. I think that's one of the things that the Legislature respects out of my administration is that we just want to get the job done, and we want to get it done better for Arizona voters.”