Neighborhood sues Phoenix over Ahwatukee data center

Carbonatix Pre-Player Loader

Audio By Carbonatix

(The Center Square) – A collective of neighbors on the southern fringes of Phoenix have taken the first step toward filing an $11 million lawsuit against the city over a data center development.


The dispute is over Menlo Digital’s 38-acre, five-building data center near the intersection of 48th Street and Thistle Landing Drive in Ahwatukee. The litigation is being brought by attorney Anthony J. Ramirez of Ramirez Law Group.


On Friday, Ramirez told The Center Square that his Notice of Claim against the city is being brought on behalf of the Ahwatukee Community Alliance, which spoke out against the development at Attorney General Kris Mayes’ town hall in October in Mesa.


Richie Taylor, chief of staff for Mayes, said the recently reelected Democratic attorney general could not comment on the Ahwatukee lawsuit because of her ongoing investigation into the development.


Adam Waltz, public information officer for the Phoenix City Council, said they couldn't comment on pending litigation. 


Ramirez said he’s hopeful the lawsuit will force the city to backtrack on the preliminary approval it gave to Menlo Digital in May 2024.


The longtime Phoenix area attorney said the city did not grant final approval by the time the preliminary plan expired in May of this year. He said that means any development on the site is being done illegally.


“These people have suffered damages,” Ramirez told The Center Square. “You have loss to their property value, discomfort, annoyance, loss of use of their property and a loss of enjoyment of life.”


Under Arizona law, a Notice of Claim is required before you can sue a public entity, public school or public employee for state-law damages. Claims must be filed within 180 days of when the action occurred, with a response from the city required within 60 days of that filing.


Additionally, Ramirez must file a lawsuit within one calendar year of when the action occurred. 


The Center Square reached out to representatives from Menlo Digital and the Phoenix City Council but did not get a response in time for this story.


Deposition and discovery


Ramirez said he’s looking forward to getting his notice filed on Friday, so his firm can gain deposition power, meaning it will have the ability to subpoena information on how the Menlo Digital development was approved by the city.


The final paragraph of Ramirez's notice spells out what the claimants are hoping to achieve from litigation, focusing their sights on stopping any development as soon as possible. 


"Ahwatukee Community Alliance, Inc. and members Craig Evans and Robert and Farida Falletta intend to file suit to enjoin the continued construction and development of the Thistle Technology Center because it violates the City of Phoenix Zoning Ordinance and because its construction is causing an ongoing public nuisance to members," the notice reads. 


Of the $11 million that Ramirez is fighting for, $1 million comes from property value losses by the two Ahwatukee residents specifically listed in the Notice of Claim (Craig Evans and Robert and Farida Falletta), while the rest is from damages related to what he attributed to the ongoing nuisances associated with the construction process, such as noise, pollution, dust and annoyance.


"The Ahwatukee Community Alliance, Inc. will share this fund with neighbors who are members of the Alliance and impacted by construction nuisance activity at the Thistle Technology Center," the notice reads. 


Ramirez’s main goal going forward is to force Menlo Digital to stop development entirely, helping those in the area recoup the losses that he says they’ve endured since construction began in April.


“When you are going to take something from someone, you have to give them notice,” Ramirez said. “So our position [is], and I would submit to you, that these homeowners have had their property values diminish or taken from them. They've had their enjoyment of life taken from them.”


The lawyer said he’s planning on deposing multiple members of the City Council, including Kevin Robinson and Kesha Washington, seeking to find out whether either member accepted campaign donations from Menlo Digital or anyone else affiliated with the Ahwatukee development.


“We're going to keep digging,” Ramirez said. “We're not stopping. We're going to continue until we get to the bottom of this.”

 

Salem News Channel Today

Sponsored Links

On Air & Up Next

  • The Seth Leibsohn Show
    4:00PM - 6:00PM
     
    Take a graduate student of political philosophy. Now add a love of contemporary   >>
     
  • SEKULOW
    6:00PM - 7:00PM
     
    Logan Sekulow and Will Haynes are joined by Jordan Sekulow to discuss Justice   >>
     
  • The Larry Elder Show
    7:00PM - 10:00PM
     
    Larry Elder personifies the phrase “We’ve Got a Country to Save” The “Sage from   >>
     
  • The Mark Levin Show
    10:00PM - 12:00AM
     
    Mark Levin's radio show is a mix of political and social commentary from a   >>
     
  • The Mark Levin Show
    12:00AM - 1:00AM
     
    Mark Levin's radio show is a mix of political and social commentary from a   >>
     

See the Full Program Guide